Cardiac Mechanoenergetics in silico
by Marko Vendelin, PhD (1), Peter H.İM.İBovendeerd,
PhD (2), ValdurİSaks, DSc (3) & J¸ri
Engelbrecht , DSc (1)
1. Institute of Cybernetics, Tallinn Technical University, Tallinn,
Estonia
2. Department of Biomedical Engineering, Eindhoven University
of Technology, Eindhoven, The Netherlands
3. Laboratory of Bioenergetics, Joseph Fourier University, Grenoble,
France
Received:
January 11, 2002
Key
words:
heart, intracellular energy fluxes, mathematical modeling,
actomyosin, mitochondria, contraction
Abstract
The
aim of this thesis is to investigate the link between biochemical
intracellular processes and mechanical contraction of the
cardiac muscle. First, the regulation of intracellular energy
fluxes between mitochondria and myofibrils is studied. It
is shown, that the experimentally observed metabolic stability
of the cardiac muscle is reproducible by a simple feedback
regulation mechanism, i.e., ATP consumption in myofibrils
and ATP production in mitochondria are balanced by the changes
of the high energy phosphate concentrations. Second, an important
property of energy transformation from biochemical form to
mechanical work in the cardiac muscle, the linear relationship
between the oxygen consumption and the stress-strain area,
is replicated by a cross-bridge model. Third, by using the
developed cross-bridge model, the correlation between ejection
fraction of the left ventricle and heterogeneity of sarcomere
strain, developed stress and ATP consumption in the left ventricular
wall is established. Fourth, an experimentally observed linear
relationship between oxygen consumption and the pressure-volume
area can be predicted theoretically from a linear relationship
between the oxygen consumption and the stress-strain area.
Summing up, it is shown how the macrovariables of a cardiac
muscle are interwoven with intracellular physiological processes
into a whole.
The aim of this thesis is to investigate the
link between biochemical intracellular processes and mechanical
contraction of the cardiac muscle. First, the regulation of
intracellular energy fluxes between mitochondria and myofibrils
is studied. It is shown, that the experimentally observed metabolic
stability of the cardiac muscle is reproducible by a simple
feedback regulation mechanism, i.e., ATP consumption in myofibrils
and ATP production in mitochondria are balanced by the changes
of the high energy phosphate concentrations. Second, an important
property of energy transformation from biochemical form to mechanical
work in the cardiac muscle, the linear relationship between
the oxygen consumption and the stress-strain area, is replicated
by a cross-bridge model. Third, by using the developed cross-bridge
model, the correlation between ejection fraction of the left
ventricle and heterogeneity of sarcomere strain, developed stress
and ATP consumption in the left ventricular wall is established.
Fourth, an experimentally observed linear relationship between
oxygen consumption and the pressure-volume area can be predicted
theoretically from a linear relationship between the oxygen
consumption and the stress-strain area. Summing up, it is shown
how the macrovariables of a cardiac muscle are interwoven with
intracellular physiological processes into a whole.
Keywords
heart, intracellular energy fluxes, mathematical
modeling, actomyosin, mitochondria, contraction
Introduction
The normal functioning of the heart requires
a precise interplay of several types of physiological processes:
electrical activation, energy transformation from biochemical
forms to mechanical form, blood supply through the coronary
blood vessel network, and regulation by hormones just to name
a few. It is a common practice to focus research on one aspect
of the heart functioning such as electrical activation, or mechanical
contraction, or biochemical energy transformation, and ignore
the interaction between the processes. Such partitioning has
been very successful in understanding many aspects of heart
physiology. However, the research in such areas as cardiac adaptation,
for example, requires understanding of the complex interaction
of the different types of processes in the heart. That is why
an integrative approach in the studies of the heart function
is becoming increasingly popular (see Hunter
et al. [2001] for overview). One of the examples of
this approach is electromechanics - studies of interactions
between electrical activation and contraction of the muscle
[Lab,
1996,Nickerson
et al., 2001,Kohl
and Sachs, 2001]. In this thesis, the aspect of interaction
between the biochemical intracellular processes and mechanical
contraction is investigated.
Biochemical energy is transferred to mechanical
energy of contraction through hydrolysis of adenosine triphosphate
(ATP). The binding of ATP molecule and its hydrolysis induces
conformational changes of certain enzymes leading to mechanical
contraction of the muscle. According to thermodynamic laws,
the amount of energy discharged during hydrolysis depends on
the levels of ATP and the products of the hydrolysis reaction
- adenosine diphosphate (ADP) and inorganic phosphate (Pi).
Since the concentrations of ATP, ADP and Pi are
different in the different compartments of the cell, the local
concentrations of the metabolites close to the enzymes determine
the amount of energy available for the mechanical contraction.
For normal cellular functioning, the local levels of ATP, ADP
and Pi have to be controlled. In other words,
a balance between ATP consumption and production in a cell has
to be maintained. This is accomplished through several mechanisms.
In the cardiac muscle cell, the processes regulating ATP, ADP
and Pi concentrations are mitochondrial oxidative
phosphorylation and the creatine kinase (CK) reaction. During
the oxidative phosphorylation process in the mitochondrion,
an ATP molecule is synthesized from the hydrolysis reaction
products ADP and Pi. ATP and ADP concentrations are
also maintained through the CK reaction which rephosphorylates
ADP to ATP at the expense of phosphocreatine (PCr). The CK reaction
is reversible and may rephosphorylate creatine (Cr) to PCr using
ATP if needed. This rephosphorylation occurs in the functional
complex of CK and adenine nucleotide translocase on the inner
membrane of mitochondrion [Wallimann
et al., 1992,Saks
et al., 1994]. In the cardiac muscle cell, the main
ATP consuming (mechanical contraction) and ATP producing (oxidative
phosphorylation) processes are spatially separated. Mechanical
contraction occurs in myofibrils and oxidative phosphorylation
in mitochondria. It is known that there exists a flux of ATP
and PCr to ATP consuming from ATP producing enzymes (see Saks
and Ventura-Clapier [1994] and Saks
et al. [1998] for overview). Such flux is sometimes
called ``energy'' flux indicating importance of both the metabolites
for a cell. Regardless of the large amount of research in this
area of intracellular energetics, the regulatory mechanism which
balances ATP consumption and ATP production and maintains the
energy fluxes in the muscle cell is still unknown. Below, the
research in this area is overviewed.
Transformation of biochemical energy of ATP
hydrolysis to mechanical energy of contraction occurs in myofilaments.
According to the sliding filament theory, actin and myosin filaments
(main filaments in myofibrils) slide along each other leading
to contraction of the muscle. The filaments interact with each
other through cross-bridges, small myosin molecule heads that
link myosin and actin filaments. The cross-bridges are supposed
to change configuration during ATP hydrolysis in such a way
that the relative position of actin and myosin filaments is
changed (see Pollack
[1995] for alternative theories of contraction).
Several models of muscle contraction exist,
from phenomenological models that describe certain properties
of the muscle contraction [Arts
et al., 1982,Hunter
et al., 1998] to cross-bridge models which are often
used to gain insight into the mechanisms of the muscle contraction.
Actually, cross-bridge models include also phenomenological
description but at a finer level. The cross-bridge models have
been used in the cardiac muscle research for more than three
decades [Wong,
1971] and have been used to relate the development of the
mechanical stress to ATP consumption by the muscle [Panerai,
1980]. Several important mechanoenergetic properties of
the cardiac muscle were not reproduced by the cross-bridge models
[Taylor
et al., 1993,Taylor
et al., 1993] leaving a gap between the experimental
knowledge and our theoretical understanding of the muscle contraction
processes [Gibbs
and Chapman, 1985,Gibbs
and Barclay, 1995].
There is a special class of cross-bridge models
which are based on the thermodynamic theory of the muscle contraction
developed by T.L. Hill and Eisenberg [Hill,
1974,Hill, 1975,Eisenberg
et al., 1980,Eisenberg
and Hill, 1985]. The models, developed on the basis of this
theory, take into account the free energy available from the
hydrolysis of ATP, the amount of mechanical work performed by
cross-bridges and the free energy of the different cross-bridge
configurations. The studies performed with this type of models
successfully reproduced several important aspects of skeletal
muscle contraction including the influence of metabolite levels
on the contraction [Cooke
and Pate, 1985,Pate
and Cooke, 1989] and ATP consumption of rapidly contracting
muscles [Cooke
et al., 1994]. In this overview, a cross-bridge model
that is able to reproduce several important mechanoenergetic
properties of cardiac muscle is described. The transformation
of biochemical energy to energy of mechanical contraction of
the left ventricle is not only dependent on the properties of
the myofibrils (material properties) but on the alignment of
the fibrils (geometrical properties or structure) in the heart
as well. The importance of this structural component to the
properties of the left ventricle is also overviewed.
The objective of this thesis is to investigate
the link between energetics and mechanical contraction of the
cardiac muscle at intracellular, muscle tissue and left ventricle
levels. For that, mathematical modeling is used with careful
testing the properties of models against the biochemical and
physiological experiments. Provided the models describe satisfactorily
the test problems, they can be further used for prediction and
explanation of the phenomena listed above.
The thesis consists of publications [Vendelin
et al., 2000,Saks
et al., 2000,Saks
et al., 2000,Vendelin
et al., 2000,Engelbrecht
et al., 2000,Vendelin
et al., submitted] and this overview. The text in the
overview is organized into four sections. This introduction
should provide the reader with background information necessary
for reading any of the following two sections in any order.
Each of these two sections gives a short overview of a particular
research field and outlines the main results obtained in this
thesis. In the second section,, specific properties of intracellular
energy fluxes regulation are outlined [Vendelin
et al., 2000,Saks
et al., 2000,Saks
et al., 2000]. In the third section, the studies of
connection between mechanical stress developed by actomyosin
complex and ATPase activity of this complex at tissue [Vendelin
et al., 2000,Engelbrecht
et al., 2000] and left ventricle [Vendelin
et al., submitted] levels are overviewed. In addition,
the influence of the alignment of the muscle fibers on the overall
performance of the left ventricle is described [Vendelin
et al., submitted]. The conclusions are drawn in the
last section.
Intracellular energy fluxes
In the cardiac muscle cell, the rate of mitochondrial
oxidative respiration depends on the substrate and oxygen supply,
and on some intracellular factors that balance the energy consumption
by myofibrils, ionic pumps and other processes consuming energy
with ATP production by mitochondrial respiration and glycolysis.
The mitochondrial respiration may vary 20 fold, from 8-10 mmol min-1 g-1 dry weight in resting (KCl-arrested) aerobic hearts [Saks
et al., 1994] to at least 160 mmol min-1 g-1 dry weight in rat hearts [Williamson
et al., 1976]. As it has been shown by Neely
et al. [1967] and Williamson
et al. [1976], the oxygen consumption of the heart
muscle is linearly dependent on the heart workload in this range
of the workloads. The changes in the workload of the heart muscle
are often observed at constant levels of PCr, ATP and Cr, i.e. the
heart is metabolically stable [Balaban
et al., 1986] (for review see Saks
et al. [1994]). Taking into account high activity of
creatine kinase (CK) in the heart muscle and assuming that the
CK reaction is in equilibrium, such remarkable metabolic stability
of the heart muscle leaves no room to explanation of respiration
regulation in conditions of sufficient oxygen and substrate
supply by simple feedback mechanism through the changes in concentrations
of participating high energy phosphates. On the basis of quantitative
analysis, Korzeniewski
[1998] proposed that energy-producing and -consuming processes
are activated in parallel leaving only the fine-tuning to the
feedback mechanism. Again, equilibrium state of the CK reaction
was assumed. As it will be shown later, this is an important
assumption and not always a correct one.
The second important assumption often used
in the analysis of intracellular energy transfer between mitochondria
and ATPases is as follows. The gradients of the metabolites
in the intracellular space are supposed to be small due to relatively
large diffusion coefficient of the metabolites measured in the
tissue and small diffusion distances within the cell.
Recently, Aliev
and Saks [1997] developed a mathematical model to analyze
the fluxes of the metabolites between mitochondria and ATPases.
The model took into account actual CK activity in the heart
cell, functional coupling between CK and adenine nucleotide
translocase (ANT) [Wallimann
et al., 1992,Saks
et al., 1994], and simulated diffusion between the
mitochondrion and myofibril as one-dimensional process. According
to the analysis of the model solution, myofibrillar CK reaction
is in the equilibrium only during the diastole and is far from
equilibrium during the systole. Thus, at least at higher workloads
as used by Aliev
and Saks [1997], it is wrong to assume that the CK reaction
is in equilibrium.
In the studies of intracellular energy transfer
conducted as a part of this thesis, we checked whether it is
possible to explain the metabolic stability of the heart muscle
by feedback regulation mechanism taking into account measured
activities of the enzymes.
Model design
In short, the model was composed on the basis
of two earlier simpler models: (1) model of energy transfer
[Aliev and
Saks, 1997] and (2) model of oxidative phosphorylation [Korzeniewski,
1998,Korzeniewski
and Froncisz, 1991]. In addition, we took into account the
spatial distribution of CK and ATPases in myofibrils in transverse
and longitudinal directions [Wegmann
et al., 1992]. The maximal oxygen consumption by the
muscle was assumed to be 160 mmol min-1 g-1 dry weight as it has been measured by Williamson
et al. [1976]. The part of the model [Aliev
and Saks, 1997] describing the functional coupling between
CK and ANT was replaced by a coupling, where ANT is able to
translocate adenine nucleotides from mitochondrial matrix to
both micro-compartment and the mitochondrial intermembrane space.
The new phenomenological equations describing CK-ANT coupling
were derived and tested against measurements of Jacobus
and Saks [1982],Saks
et al. [1975]. The constants in the mitochondrial inner
membrane proton leak function were modified to account for the
experimentally established relation between the membrane leak
and protonmotive force at different workloads [Saks
et al., 1994,Hafner
et al., 1990,Duszynski
et al., 1984]. The model equations were numerically
solved by a finite-element method in conjunction with Galerkin's
method. The complete description of the model is published in
Vendelin
et al. [2000].
Comparison with experiments
In the simulations, the linear relationship
between workload and oxygen consumption was reproduced [Vendelin
et al., 2000]. The slight nonlinearity of workload-oxygen
consumption relationship was caused by changes in the leak of
protons through the inner mitochondrial membrane. The model
describes quite satisfactorily the stable levels of PCr, ATP,
and Cr at oxygen consumption rates up to 100 mmol min-1 g-1 dry weight, in accordance with the experimental data [Vendelin
et al., 2000]. At higher workloads the drop of PCr-to-Cr
and PCr-to-ATP ratios was caused by the limitation of maximal
respiration rate of 160 mmol min-1 g-1 dry weight incorporated into the model. The metabolic stability
is reduced together with maximal achievable VO2
if the level of total creatine content is reduced [Saks
et al., 2000]. If the CK reaction is inhibited then
the maximum possible VO2 is only 41 mmol min-1 g-1 dry weight in agreement with the measured maximum VO2
= 35-50 mmol min-1 g-1 dry weight in similar conditions [Saks
et al., 1998,Hamman
et al., 1995,Zweier
et al., 1991,Saupe
et al., 1998]. We reproduced ADP oscillations during
the cardiac cycle predicted by the simulations of Aliev
and Saks [1997]. The amplitude of ADP oscillations was increasing
with an increase of the workload [Vendelin
et al., 2000]. The average level of computed inorganic
phosphate Pi was low at low to moderate workloads
[Vendelin
et al., 2000] in accordance with NMR measurements
performed on pyruvate perfused hearts [Santos
et al., 2000]. Thus, it is possible to reproduce the
measurements of PCr, ATP, and Cr levels at different workloads
by simple feedback regulation mechanism. It is important to
note that this finding does not rule out the parallel regulation
mechanism proposed by Korzeniewski
[1998], it just shows that the parallel regulation is not
required to explain the metabolic stability of the heart muscle.
Our model predicts an interesting feature of
the regulation mechanism: the mitochondrial respiration is regulated
by different cytoplasmic metabolites depending on the workload
and CK activity. At low and moderate workloads, the oxidative
phosphorylation is regulated by cytoplasmic Pi providing
the required feedback signal and possibility for constant PCr-to-ATP
ratio [Saks
et al., 2000]. This result is in concord with the following
experimental observation: if the Pi is increased
as in glucose perfused hearts the metabolic stability is lost
[Santos
et al., 2000]. In other words, with non-limiting Pi concentration
oxidative phosphorylation is regulated by other means, such
as PCr, ATP and Cr levels. At higher workloads the regulation
is shared among the participating metabolites. If CK is inhibited,
the oxidative phosphorylation is mainly regulated by cytoplasmic
ADP level [Saks
et al., 2000].
The intracellular gradients computed by the
model were very small if diffusion coefficient measured in the
cell was used [Vendelin
et al., 2000]. When diffusion coefficient was reduced
ten-fold, the difference of ADP concentration between myofibrillar
core and myoplastic side of mitochondrial outer membrane was
0.2 mM. Taking into account that ADP concentration in the myofibrils
in the resting state is about 50 mM, the computed gradient is relatively large. However, such gradient in ADP concentration
should not influence ATPase activity of actomyosin complex in
the healthy heart muscle if ATP concentration (about 9-10 mM)
is taken into account.
We checked the influence of small gradients
to the model solution by eliminating the metabolite concentration
gradients through the increase of the diffusion coefficient
by 105 times. According to our simulations, there
was no difference between the original solution and the solution
obtained with the very fast diffusion [Vendelin
et al., 2000]. On the basis of these results, it is
reasonable to use simpler ordinary differential equations based
(ODE) models to study intracellular fluxes in the cardiac cell.
These simpler models can be included into the finite element
models of the heart to study distribution of the metabolites
in the heart wall. ODE based version of our model is published
in [Vendelin
et al., 2000].
Cardiac mechanoenergetics
In
the heart, the energy of ATP hydrolysis is transformed into mechanical
work of the cardiac muscle. This transformation occurs in the
actomyosin complex, aligned into the filaments in the heart, as
a result of cyclic interaction of myosin heads with actin filaments
[Huxley,
1990,Irving,
1985,Saeki,
1995]. The transformation of the actomyosin complex is driven
by the free energy of ATP hydrolysis to ADP and Pi
[Goldman, 1987,Saeki,
1995,Taylor,
1992]. The mechanical performance of the ventricle depends
on both the properties of the actomyosin complex and fiber orientation
within the left ventricular wall. Here, the properties of the
actomyosin complex and influence of fiber orientation on the left
ventricular performance were studied. More specific overviews
of those problems are given below.
Mechanoenergetics of actomyosin interaction
One important property of the cardiac muscle
which links the energy consumption of the muscle with mechanical
output is as follows. The oxygen consumption of the ventricle
is linearly related to the pressure-volume area (PVA), the specific
area in pressure-volume (PV) diagram surrounded by the end-systolic
PV line, the end-diastolic PV line, and the systolic segment
of the PV trajectory for a contraction [Suga
et al., 1981,Suga,
1990]. A similar relationship was identified at the tissue
level - the oxygen consumption of the cardiac muscle is linearly
related to the stress-strain area, an analog of PVA [Hisano
and Cooper, 1987]. In spite of the large amount of experimental
evidence supporting the linear dependency between oxygen consumption
and SSA, computations performed using Huxley-type models have
always predicted a nonlinear relationship between these two
variables [Taylor
et al., 1993,Taylor
et al., 1993]. The importance of resolving this discrepancy
between the current theoretical understanding of muscle contraction
and fundamental property of cardiac muscle has been outlined
in several reviews [Gibbs
and Chapman, 1985,Gibbs
and Barclay, 1995].
As a part of our research, we composed a cross-bridge
model using the formalism developed by T.L. Hill and Eisenberg
[Hill, 1974,Eisenberg
et al., 1980,Eisenberg
and Hill, 1985]. The main difference between our model and
the cardiac muscle cross-bridge models that were used to compute
ATP consumption dependency on SSA before [Taylor
et al., 1993,Taylor
et al., 1993], was the approach we used to obtain the
model parameters. Namely, one of the requirements used in the
model parameters estimation was the linear dependency between
ATP consumption and SSA in isometric and shortening contractions.
Thus, we treated the relationship between ATP consumption and
SSA as a fundamental property of the muscle and found the cross-bridge
cycling rate constants and the activation parameters using this
macroscopical property of the muscle. When this approach was
applied the following properties of the cardiac muscle were
reproduced [Vendelin
et al., 2000]: (a) the relationship between ATP consumption
and SSA is linear, with contractile efficiency close to the
measured one; (b) the computed isometric active stress during
a beat replicates well the measured stress in the isosarcometric
contraction at different sarcomere length values [Janssen
and Hunter, 1995]; (c) the contraction duration is smaller
in the isotonic case if compared with the isometric case, which
reproduces the typical isotonic contraction experiment results
[Brutsaert
et al., 1978]; (d) the end-systolic point in the stress-strain
diagram in isotonic contraction lies close to the end-systolic
line computed for the isometric case [Hisano
and Cooper, 1987]. The model was able to predict the following
properties of the muscle: (a) shortening velocity-afterload
relationship at afterloads higher than 2.5 kPa [van
Heuningen et al., 1982]; (b) drop of ATP consumption
by the cross-bridges during a cycle by about 40% if the muscle
is released at the time of peak force [Hisano
and Cooper, 1987].
It is possible to use the developed cardiac
muscle cross-bridge model as a part of left ventricle or complete
heart models using the formalism of internal state variables
[Engelbrecht
et al., 2000]. On the example of the cardiac muscle,
we have shown that the internal variables reflecting microstructural
properties of soft biological tissues may be organized into
a hierarchy. This hierarchical structure incorporates the cross-bridge
state distribution functions and the variables describing the
activation of the actomyosin complex by calcium ions as used
in [Vendelin
et al., 2000].
Fiber orientation in the ventricle
It has been shown theoretically [Bovendeerd
et al., 1994], that the distribution of stress and
strain in the left ventricular wall is highly sensitive to the
changes in the fiber orientation within the wall. Taking into
account such sensitivity, the fiber orientation has to be regulated
carefully in the ventricles by adaptation processes. Indeed,
depending on the adaptation case, the fibers may be reoriented
[Ursell
et al., 1985] or remain similar to the orientation
in the normal heart [Carew
and Covell, 1979,Omens
and Covell, 1991]. Here, we investigated the influence of
fiber orientation on the ejection fraction and the heterogeneity
of the distributions of fiber stress, fiber strain and ATP consumption
[Vendelin
et al., submitted].
A finite element model similar to [Bovendeerd
et al., 1994] was used with active properties described
by the Huxley-type cross-bridge model [Vendelin
et al., 2000]. The model computes the deformation of
the ventricle, local strains, passive and active stress, and
ATP consumption in the ventricular wall. The governing equations
were discretized using the finite element method in conjunction
with Galerkin's method. The fiber orientation was quantified
by two angles: the helix fiber angle, describing the crossover
of fibers between base and apex of the heart, and the transverse
angle, describing the crossover of fibers between inner and
outer layers of the cardiac wall. According to our simulations
[Vendelin
et al., submitted], the variances of the sarcomere
length, developed stress and ATP consumption during a beat have
very similar dependencies on transmural course of the helix
fiber angle. The optimal transverse angle value is also similar
if the variance of the sarcomere length or developed stress
is minimized. The dependence of sarcomere length, developed
stress and ATP consumption variances on the helix fiber angle
distribution is not simple: the variances have several minima
at different helix fiber angle distributions. However, we identified
only one region in the studied design space with high ejection
fraction of the left ventricle and relatively homogeneous distributions
of sarcomere strain, developed stress and ATP consumption within
the ventricular wall. This region corresponds to the physiological
distribution of the helix fiber angle in the LV wall [Streeter,
1979,Nielsen
et al., 1991,Rijcken,
1997]. From our analysis we concluded that if the fiber
orientation is regulated by strain or stress distribution the
adaptation process should be stable and lead to the ventricles
with high ejection fraction provided the difference between
actual and optimal fiber orientation is relatively small.
In [Vendelin
et al., submitted], a linear PVA-ATP consumption relationship
was obtained. Since we used the cross-bridge model [Vendelin
et al., 2000] which reproduced linear SSA-ATP
consumption relationship, the measured PVA-ATP relationship
can be predicted theoretically from the SSA-ATP relationship.
The computed ATP consumption distribution was similar to the
distribution of oxygen consumption estimated from PCr-to-ATP
ratio measurements by NMR. According to the measurements, PCr-to-ATP
ratio is slightly higher in the epicardial layer than in the
endocardial layer and, with a midwall layer value between these
two [Gong
et al., 1999,Zhang
and McDonald, 1995]. From the available PCr-to-ATP ratio
measurements, one can conclude that oxygen consumption in epicardial
layers is lower than in endocardial layers. According to our
simulations, the highest ATP consumption rate is between the
midwall and endocardial layers and the smallest ATP consumption
in sub-epicardial layer.
Conclusions
The studies in this thesis are focused on the
mechanoenergetics of the cardiac muscle, starting from the regulation
of intracellular energy fluxes up to the behavior of the left
ventricle as a whole. Below, the main conclusions, grouped according
to physiological processes are reported.
From the analysis of intracellular energy fluxes
in the cardiac cell, the following conclusion was made:
- It is possible to reproduce the metabolic
stability of the cardiac muscle cell using simple feedback
regulation mechanism at low and moderate workloads.
The regulatory mechanism used in the cardiac muscle
cells has to be identified from combined experimental and theoretical
studies. However, the relatively simple feedback mechanism based
on the changes of the high energy phosphates can not be ruled
out on the basis of available experimental data yet. From the
computer simulations on the regulatory role of participating metabolites,
the following was concluded:
- The regulator metabolite of the oxidative
respiration is not fixed, but depends on the workload and
enzyme availability.
Thus, there is most probably no universal regulator
of the oxidative phosphorylation of the cardiac muscle mitochondria,
but the regulatory role is shared among the participating metabolites.
In the muscle, the energy of biochemical reactions
is transformed to the mechanical energy of muscle contraction.
The following results were obtained in the theoretical studies
of cardiac muscle contraction mechanism:
- It is possible to reproduce the experimentally
observed linear relation between ATP consumption and stress-strain
area with a model, composed of a 3-state Huxley-type model
for cross-bridge interaction and a phenomenological model
of Ca2+-induced activation.
- The linear relationship between the stress-strain
area and ATP consumption does not imply a high amount of the
``passenger'' cross-bridges, i.e. cross-bridges that
detach without hydrolyzing ATP molecule.
The developed cross-bridge model of cardiac muscle
contraction was used in the studies of the left ventricle mechanoenergetics.
The properties of the left ventricle do not
depend only on the properties of the muscle cells, but on the
alignment of the cells in the wall as well. The following conclusion
has been reached from the analysis of the model solution:
- The variances of sarcomere strain and developed
stress are minimized by almost the same fiber orientation,
which is close to the measured one. There exists a local minimum
of the sarcomere strain and stress variances in the region
that corresponds to a high ejection fraction of the left ventricle.
At this minimum, the distribution of ATP consumption in the
left ventricular wall is relatively homogeneous.
From this result it can be concluded that, if the
orientation of the muscle fibers in the left ventricle is regulated
by the adaptation process to minimize the heterogeneity of the
strain or stress distribution in the left ventricular wall, the
resulting design of the left ventricle will lead to a good left
ventricle performance as a pump.
Finally, by using the cross-bridge model composed
in this thesis as a part of the left ventricle finite element
model, the following was demonstrated:
- A linear relationship between ATP consumption
and the pressure-volume area can be predicted theoretically
from a linear relationship between ATP consumption and the
stress-strain area.
References
- [1]
- P. J. Hunter, P. Kohl, and D. Noble.
Integrative models of the heart: achievements and limitations.
Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A, 359: 1049-1054, 2001.
- [2]
- P. Kohl and F. Sachs. Mechanoelectric
feedback in cardiac cells. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond.
A, 359: 1173-1185, 2001.
- [3]
- M. J. Lab. Mechanoelectric feedback
(transduction) in heart: concepts and implications. Cardiovasc
Res, 32 (1): 3-14, Jul 1996.
- [4]
- D. P. Nickerson, N. P. Smith,
and P. J. Hunter. A model of cardiac cellular electromechanics.
Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A, 359: 1159-1172, 2001.
- [5]
- V. A. Saks, Z. A. Khuchua, E. V.
Vasilyeva, O. Yu. Belikova, and A. V. Kuznetsov.
Metabolic compartmentation and substrate channeling in muscle
cells. Mol. Cell. Biochem., 133/134: 155-192, Apr/May
1994.
- [6]
- T. Wallimann, M. Wyss, D. Brdiczka,
K. Nicolay, and H. M. Eppenberger. Intracellular
compartmentation, structure and function of creatine kinase
isoenzymes in tissues with high and fluctuating energy demands:
the 'phosphocreatine circuit' for cellular energy homeostasis.
Biochem J, 281 ( Pt 1): 21-40, Jan 1992.
- [7]
- V. A. Saks and R. Ventura-Clapier,
editors. Cellular Bioenergetics: Role of Coupled Creatine
Kinases. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, 1994.
- [8]
- V. A. Saks, R. Ventura-Clapier,
X. Leverve, A. Rossi, and M. Rigoulet, editors.
Bioenergetics of the Cell: Quantitative Aspects.
Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, 1998a.
- [9]
- G. H. Pollack. Muscle contraction mechanism:
are alternative engines gathering steam? Cardiovasc Res,
29 (6): 737-46; discussion 747-57, Jun 1995.
- [10]
- T. Arts, P. C. Veenstra, and R. S.
Reneman. Epicardial deformation and left ventricular wall
mechanisms during ejection in the dog. Am J Physiol,
243 (3): H379-H390, Sep 1982.
- [11]
- P. J. Hunter, A. D. McCulloch,
and H. E. ter Keurs. Modelling the mechanical properties
of cardiac muscle. Prog Biophys Mol Biol, 69 (2-3):
289-331, 1998.
- [12]
- A. Y. Wong. Mechanics of cardiac muscle,
based on Huxley's model: mathematical stimulation of isometric
contraction. J Biomech, 4 (6): 529-540, Dec 1971.
- [13]
- R. B. Panerai. A model of cardiac muscle
mechanics and energetics. J Biomech, 13 (11): 929-940,
1980.
- [14]
- T. W. Taylor, Y. Goto, K. Hata,
T. Takasago, A. Saeki, T. Nishioka, and H. Suga.
Comparison of the cardiac force-time integral with energetics
using a cardiac muscle model. J Biomech, 26 (10):
1217-1225, Oct 1993a.
- [15]
- T. W. Taylor, Y. Goto, and H. Suga.
Variable cross-bridge cycling-ATP coupling accounts for cardiac
mechanoenergetics. Am J Physiol, 264 (3 Pt 2): H994-1004,
Mar 1993b.
- [16]
- C. L. Gibbs and C. J. Barclay.
Cardiac efficiency. Cardiovasc Res, 30 (5): 627-634,
Nov 1995.
- [17]
- C. L. Gibbs and J. B. Chapman.
Cardiac mechanics and energetics: chemomechanical transduction
in cardiac muscle. Am J Physiol, 249 (2 Pt 2): H199-H206,
Aug 1985.
- [18]
- E. Eisenberg and T. L. Hill. Muscle
contraction and free energy transduction in biological systems.
Science, 227 (4690): 999-1006, Mar 1985.
- [19]
- E. Eisenberg, T. L. Hill, and
Y. Chen. Cross-bridge model of muscle contraction. Quantitative
analysis. Biophys J, 29 (2): 195-227, Feb 1980.
- [20]
- T. L. Hill. Theoretical formalism for
the sliding filament model of contraction of striated muscle.
Part I. Prog Biophys Mol Biol, 28: 267-340, 701 1974.
- [21]
- T. L. Hill. Theoretical formalism for
the sliding filament model of contraction of striated muscle.
Part II. Prog Biophys Mol Biol, 29 (2): 105-59, 822
1975.
- [22]
- R. Cooke and E. Pate. The effects
of adp and phosphate on the contraction of muscle fibers.
Biophys J, 48 (5): 789-798, Nov 1985.
- [23]
- E. Pate and R. Cooke. A model
of crossbridge action: the effects of ATP, ADP and Pi. J
Muscle Res Cell Motil, 10 (3): 181-196, Jun 1989.
- [24]
- R. Cooke, H. White, and E. Pate.
A model of the release of myosin heads from actin in rapidly
contracting muscle fibers. Biophys J, 66 (3 Pt 1):
778-788, Mar 1994.
- [25]
- V. A. Saks, O. Kongas, M. Vendelin,
and L. Kay. Role of the creatine/phosphocreatine system
in the regulation of mitochondrial respiration. Acta Physiol
Scand, 168 (4): 635-641, Apr 2000a.
- [26]
- M. Vendelin, P. H. M. Bovendeerd,
T. Arts, J. Engelbrecht, and D. H. van Campen.
Cardiac mechanoenergetics replicated by cross-bridge model.
Ann Biomed Eng, 28 (6): 629-640, Jun 2000a.
- [27]
- M. Vendelin, P. H. Bovendeerd,
J. Engelbrecht, and T. Arts. Ventricular fibers
are oriented for high ejection fraction and uniform distribution
of strain and stress. submitted.
- [28]
- M. Vendelin, O. Kongas, and V. Saks.
Regulation of mitochondrial respiration in heart cells analyzed
by reaction-diffusion model of energy transfer. Am J Physiol
Cell Physiol, 278 (4): C747-C764, Apr 2000b.
- [29]
- V. Saks, M. Vendelin, O. Kongas,
and L. Kay. Creatine-phosphocreatine pathway in the intracellular
networks of energy transfer and signal transduction in muscle
cells. In R. Paoletti, A. Poli, and A. S. Jackson,
editors, Creatine: From Basic Science to Clinical Applications,
pages 1-9. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 2000b.
- [30]
- J. Engelbrecht, M. Vendelin, and
G. A. Maugin. Hierarchical internal variables reflecting
microstructural properties: application to cardiac muscle
contraction. J Non-Equilibrium Thermodyn, 25 (2):
119-130, 2000.
- [31]
- J. R. Williamson, C. Ford, J. Illingworth,
and B. Safer. Coordination of citric acid cycle activity
with electron transport flux. Circ. Res., 38 (5 Suppl
1): I39-I51, May 1976.
- [32]
- J. R. Neely, H. Liebermeister,
E. J. Battersby, and H. E. Morgan. Effect of pressure
development on oxygen consumption by isolated rat heart. Am
J Physiol, 212 (4): 804-814, Apr 1967.
- [33]
- R. S. Balaban, H. L. Kantor, L. A.
Katz, and R. W. Briggs. Relation between work and phosphate
metabolite in the in vivo paced mammalian heart. Science,
232 (4754): 1121-1123, May 1986.
- [34]
- B. Korzeniewski. Regulation of ATP
supply during muscle contraction: Theoretical studies. Biochem.
J., 330: 1189-1195, 1998.
- [35]
- M. K. Aliev and V. A. Saks. Compartmentalized
energy transfer in cardiomyocytes: Use of mathematical modeling
for analysis of in vivo regulation of respiration.
Biophys. J., 73: 428-445, 1997.
- [36]
- B. Korzeniewski and W. Froncisz.
An extended dynamic model of oxidative phosphorylation. Biochim.
Biophys. Acta, 1060 (2): 210-223, Oct 1991.
- [37]
- G. Wegmann, E. Zanolla, H. M.
Eppenberger, and T. Wallimann. In situ compartmentation
of creatine kinase in intact sarcomeric muscle: the acto-myosin
overlap zone as a molecular sieve. J Muscle Res Cell Motil,
13 (4): 420-435, Aug 1992.
- [38]
- W. E. Jacobus and V. A. Saks.
Creatine kinase of heart mitochondria: changes in its kinetic
properties induced by coupling to oxidative phosphorylation.
Arch Biochem Biophys, 219 (1): 167-178, Nov 1982.
- [39]
- V. A. Saks, G. B. Chernousova,
D. E. Gukovsky, V. N. Smirnov, and E. I. Chazov.
Studies of energy transport in heart cells. Mitochondrial
isoenzyme of creatine phosphokinase: kinetic properties and
regulatory action of Mg2+ ions. Eur J Biochem, 57
(1): 273-290, Sep 1975.
- [40]
- J. Duszynski, K. Bogucka, and
L. Wojtczak. Homeostasis of the protonmotive force in
phosphorylating mitochondria. Biochim. Biophys. Acta,
767: 540-547, 1984.
- [41]
- R. P. Hafner, G. C. Brown, and
M. D. Brand. Analysis of the control of respiration rate,
phosphorylation rate, proton leak rate and protonmotive force
in isolated mitochondria using the 'top-down' approach of
metabolic control theory. Eur. J. Biochem., 188 (2):
313-319, Mar 1990.
- [42]
- B. L. Hamman, J. A. Bittl, W. E.
Jacobus, P. D. Allen, R. S. Spencer, R. Tian,
and J. S. Ingwall. Inhibition of the creatine kinase
reaction decreases the contractile reserve of isolated rat
hearts. Am. J. Physiol., 269 (3 Pt 2): H1030-H1036,
Sep 1995.
- [43]
- V. Saks, P. Dos Santos, F. N.
Gellerich, and P. Diolez. Quantitative studies of enzyme-substrate
compartmentation, functional coupling and metabolic channeling
in muscle cells. Mol. Cell. Biochem., 184: 291-307,
1998b.
- [44]
- K. W. Saupe, M. Spindler, R. Tian,
and J. S. Ingwall. Impaired cardiac energetics in mice
lacking muscle-specific isoenzymes of creatine kinase. Circ.
Res., 82 (8): 898-907, May 1998.
- [45]
- J. L. Zweier, W. E. Jacobus, B. Korecky,
and Y. Brandejs-Barry. Bioenergetic consequences of cardiac
phosphocreatine depletion induced by creatine analogue feeding.
J. Biol. Chem., 266 (30): 20296-20304, Oct 1991.
- [46]
- P. Dos Santos, M. K. Aliev, P. Diolez,
F. Duclos, P. Besse, S. Bonoron-Adele, P. Sikk,
P. Canioni, and V. A. Saks. Metabolic control of
contractile performance in isolated perfused rat heart. Analysis
of experimental data by reaction:diffusion mathematical model.
J Mol Cell Cardiol, 32 (9): 1703-1734, Sep 2000.
- [47]
- H. E. Huxley. Sliding filaments and
molecular motile systems. J Biol Chem, 265 (15):
8347-8350, May 1990.
- [48]
- M. Irving. Weak and strong crossbridges.
Nature, 316 (6026): 292-293, Jul 1985.
- [49]
- Y. Saeki. Crossbridge dynamics under
various inotropic states in cardiac muscle: evaluation by
perturbation analyses. Jpn J Physiol, 45 (5): 687-705,
1995.
- [50]
- Y. E. Goldman. Kinetics of the actomyosin
ATPase in muscle fibers. Annu Rev Physiol, 49: 637-654,
519 1987.
- [51]
- E. W. Taylor. Mechanism and energetics
of actomyosin ATPase. In H. A. Fozzard, E. Haber,
R. B. Jennings, A. M. Katz, and H. E. Morgan,
editors, The heart and cardiovascular system, pages
1281-1294. Raven Press, New York, 2nd edition, 1992.
- [52]
- H. Suga. Ventricular energetics. Physiol
Rev, 70 (2): 247-277, Apr 1990.
- [53]
- H. Suga, T. Hayashi, and M. Shirahata.
Ventricular systolic pressure-volume area as predictor of
cardiac oxygen consumption. Am J Physiol, 240 (1):
H39-H44, Jan 1981.
- [54]
- R. Hisano and G. Cooper. Correlation
of force-length area with oxygen consumption in ferret papillary
muscle. Circ Res, 61 (3): 318-328, Sep 1987.
- [55]
- P. M. Janssen and W. C. Hunter.
Force, not sarcomere length, correlates with prolongation
of isosarcometric contraction. Am J Physiol, 269
(2 Pt 2): H676-H685, Aug 1995.
- [56]
- D. L. Brutsaert, N. M. de Clerck,
M. A. Goethals, and P. R. Housmans. Relaxation of
ventricular cardiac muscle. J Physiol (Lond), 283:
469-480, Oct 1978.
- [57]
- R. van Heuningen, W. H. Rijnsburger,
and H. E. ter Keurs. Sarcomere length control in striated
muscle. Am J Physiol, 242 (3): H411-H420, Mar 1982.
- [58]
- P. H. M. Bovendeerd, J. M.
Huyghe, T. Arts, D. H. van Campen, and R. S.
Reneman. Influence of endocardial-epicardial crossover of
muscle fibers on left ventricular wall mechanics. J Biomech,
27 (7): 941-951, Jul 1994.
- [59]
- P. C. Ursell, P. I. Gardner, A. Albala,
J. J. Fenoglio Jr., and A. L. Wit. Structural and
electrophysiological changes in the epicardial border zone
of canine myocardial infarcts during infarct healing. Circ
Res, 56 (3): 436-451, Mar 1985.
- [60]
- T. E. Carew and J. W. Covell.
Fiber orientation in hypertrophied canine left ventricle.
Am J Physiol, 236 (3): H487-H493, Mar 1979.
- [61]
- J. H. Omens and J. W. Covell.
Transmural distribution of myocardial tissue growth induced
by volume-overload hypertrophy in the dog. Circulation,
84 (3): 1235-1245, Sep 1991.
- [62]
- P. M. Nielsen, I. J. Le Grice,
B. H. Smaill, and P. J. Hunter. Mathematical model
of geometry and fibrous structure of the heart. Am J Physiol,
260 (4 Pt 2): H1365-H1378, Apr 1991.
- [63]
- J. Rijcken. Optimization of left
ventricular muscle fiber orientation. PhD thesis, Universiteit
Maastricht, 1997. ISBN 90-9010880-7.
- [64]
- D. D. Streeter. Gross morphology and
fiber geometry of the heart. In R. M. Berne, editor,
Handbook of physiology - The cardiovascular system I,
pages 61-122. Am. Physiol. Soc., Bethesda, MD, 1979.
- [65]
- G. Gong, K. Ugurbil, and J. Zhang.
Transmural metabolic heterogeneity at high cardiac work states.
Am J Physiol, 277 (1 Pt 2): H236-H242, Jul 1999.
- [66]
- J. Zhang and K. M. McDonald. Bioenergetic
consequences of left ventricular remodeling. Circulation,
92 (4): 1011-1019, Aug 1995.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank Prof. Theo Arts,
Maastricht, the Netherlands, Prof. Dick van Campen, Eindhoven,
the Netherlands and Dr. Olav Kongas, Tallinn, Estonia for support
of this work and fruitful discussions. The research covered
in this paper has been partially supported by the Estonian Science
Foundation and the Netherlands Organization for International
Cooperation in Higher Education.
File translated from TEX by
TTH, version 2.92.
On 11 Jan 2002, 18:44. |