INVITED GUEST EDITORIAL
by Ario Conti and Georges J. M. Maestroni
December 1, 1999
Congress Report:
International Congress of Neuroimmunomodulation, ISNIM-99
Science and
art need not be in conflict because both require use of
imagination, cognitive insight, discipline and creative application.
Conceptual shifts in neuroimmunoscience have offered new validity
to intuitive belief regarding the connection between mind
body unit, external and/or internal stimuli such as
viruses and bacteria, primordial environmental stimuli such
as light:dark cycle, moon cycle, humidity, etc.... In the
last two decades many new factors such as climate changes,
air pollution, and their social and environmental effects
are becoming increasingly sophisticated.
On the other hand
research on NIM and its interdisciplinary research spanning
immunology, neurobiology, neuroendocrinology, and behavioral
sciences is growing exponentially; indeed, it may be the fastest
growing field in biomedical sciences. The International Society
for Neuroimmunomodulation, founded only a few years ago (1985
Dubrovnik), now has active members in 40 countries. This revolution
in the basic sciences will undoubtedly lead to a corresponding
revolution in clinical practice and, most importantly, in the
area of preventive medicine.
Modern scientific
evidence of interactions among the nervous, endocrine and immune
systems dates from the late nineteenth century, although this
concept was certainly known to the ancients in Asia, Europe,
Africa, and the Americas. In the past two decades, the mechanisms
of these interactions, known today as neuroimmunomodulation
(NIM), have been investigated from subcellular to the behavioral
levels, using the modern tools of receptors and membrane physiology,
biochemistry, pharmacology, immunology, chronobiology, and genetics.
Proceedings of different ISNIM congresses have been published
with a great success and a large number of papers have been
accepted: the previous volumes on neuroimmunomodulation research
such as the Proceedings of the First International Workshop
on NIM (1984) Bethesda, USA [Spector et al., 1985], Neuroimmune
interactions: proceedings of the Second International Workshop
on Neuroimmunomodulation, May 1987, Dubrovnik, Yugoslavia
[Jankovic et al., 1987], Ontogenetic and phylogenetic mechanisms
of neuroimmunomodulation (1990) Florence, Italy [Fabris
et al., 1992] and Neuroimmunomodulation: molecular aspects,
integrative systems and clinical advances (1996) Bethesda,
USA [McCann et al., 1998] constitute a four-volume state-of-the-art
collection representing most of the areas of research in the
exponentially growing field of neuroimmunomodulation.
Tables of contents
of this basic book of NIM suggest some of the depth and breadth
of the subject matter: molecular biology, genetics, neurosciences,
immunology, cell biology, physiology, endocrinology, chronobiology,
pharmacology, anatomy, biochemistry and the behavioral sciences,
as well as many contributions from oncologists, gerontologists
and other clinical aspects.
1987:
Dubrovnik, Yugoslavia: A new
discipline named "Neuroimmunomodulation" by
N.H. Spector or with major emphasis on behavior aspects as "Psychoneuroimmunomodulation"
as it was defined by R. Ader was born. This discipline is devoted
to study the interactions at different morphologic and functional
levels among the immune system, the nervous system and the endocrine
system. In fact this science is an old science or, as defined
by B.D. Yankovic (1987) "
neuroimmunomodulation
is a modern reflection in neurosciences and immunosciences of
the ideas and experience of philosophers and ingenious observers
of ancient Egypt, Greece, China, India and other old civilizations
that the mind is involved in the defense against diseases
"
1999:
Lugano, Switzerland: 12 years ago NIM was regarded by many
conventional scientists as a kind of witchcraft. Today it may
be the fastest growing area of research in the biomedical sciences
in the world. More than 124 invited speakers and over 140 posters
on 15 different topics have been focused on the state of the
art of Neuroimmunomodulation.
Sessions devoted
to pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines evidenced the importance
of the connection and the balance between the immune, neuroendocrine
and nervous systems. In particular the role of cytokines has
been stressed (for ex. IL-1a and b) and their receptors distributed
on brain and immune tissues upon infection events which induce
a release of many hormones such as CRH, VP, GHRH and somatostatin.
On the other hand a decrease of pro-inhibiting hormones, DOPA,
LH, TRH, has been reported. Moreover, alteration of infectious
agents or experimentally induced infections, such as LPS, seem
to be mediated by nitric oxide synthetase (NOS) which induces
the production of NO and, therefore, the modulation of "infection
hormones." In fact during certain pathological conditions
iNOS-derived NO is produced in the brain. Studies are in progress
to understand its role in experimental allergic encephalomyelitis,
multiple sclerosis and AIDS patients where iNOS has been observed
in microglial cells and/or infiltrating macrophages.
Interleukins stimulated
by inflammatory agents may have a negative effect on the brain.
In particular IL-1 induces brain damage, ischemia, trauma and
excitotoxic injury. Upregulation of IL-1 receptor by IL-4, IL-10
and TNF-a and the consequent inhibition of IL-1 may prevent
such damages of the brain tissue.
According to the
dialogue between the periphery and the center, peripheral inflammation
may induce the brain to produce IL-1b, IL-6 and TNF-a. Such
cytokines injected with small non pyrogenic doses induce hyperanalgesia
which seems to be caused by PGE2 which in turn acts on EP3 of
the hypothalamus, while injection of the same cytokines with
high pyrogenic doses induce analgesia via PGE2 on EP1 hypothalamic
receptor. Consequently to an infection action and pyrogenic
effects, some scientists are working on the role of antipyrogenic
molecules. Among them a-MSH, arginine, vasopressin, glucocorticoids,
TNF-a, IL-10 and the most recent P450 which is a cytochrome
of the arachidonic metabolism and appears to be the contrebalance
of PGE.
Inflammation has
been since many years connected with stress phenomena. Experimental
evidence supports that stress hormones such as glucocorticoids,
catecholamines (epinephrine, norepinephrine) and histamine are
modulating TNF-a, IL-12 and Il-10. In particular these end products
of stress inhibit TNF-a and IL-12 on TH1,
while they stimulate IL-10 which from one side inhibits TH1
and on the other hand stimulates TH2
and tumoral activity. The balance TH1
vs TH2
and vice versa through stress hormones may increase the susceptibility
of the organism to certain viral or bacterial intracellular
infections or tumors that are protected against by TH1
dependent immunity. The same for Lupus erythematosus and atopic
reactions that are dominated by TH2
response.
Among hormonal effects
and roles of a-MSH have been largely investigated in NIM. a-MSH
is a peptide involved in fever, inflammation and microbial invasion.
In inflammatory cells, both at the peripheral levels and at
the central nervous system, the production of proinflammatory
cytokines is modulated . a-MSH neuroimmunomodulation has been
evidenced in cutaneous inflammation as well as in delayed type
hypersensitivity. More generally, skin produces a-MSH and melanocortin
receptor-1 (MC-R1) is expressed on the tissue. Moreover, the
production of inflammatory cytokines such as IL-2, IFN-g and
IL-1 by monocytes, macrophages and dendritic cells is modulated
by a-MSH. A down regulation of dendritic cells (CD86) and pre
B cells (CD40) by a-MSH with a stimulation of IL-10 has been
also reported. The action of a-MSH as modulators of cutaneous
inflammation can be summarized as 1) general action on peripheral
host cells, 2) through action on host cells within the brain
to moderate local inflammation and 3) via descending neural
antiinflammatory pathways that control inflammation in peripheral
tissues. Prolactin and GH, which in parallel with a-MSH are
largely studied by neuroimmunologists, are involved in many
neuroimmunomodulatory and hematopoietic mechanisms: in particular
prolactin has been involved as a survival factor for T lymphocytes
in early and late T-lymphocyte activation events such as immune
response, in autoimmune diseases and tumor/viral cell defense.
On the other hand
lymphocytes, and perhaps particularly B lymphocytes, participate
actively in the complex interaction between GH and the immune
system. Both prolactin (PRL) and growth hormone (GH) present
a pleiotropic action, which is necessary for vertebrate growth,
mammary differentiation and immune system function. Many studies
using different models in vitro (granulocytes, neutrophiles,
thymocytes, NB2 T-cell line, human-B lymphoblastoid cell line
IM-9, etc...) as well as molecular biology models (RT-PCR, western-blot
analysis, receptor detection and binding affinity, detection
of PRL and GH-gene, etc...) are in progress to understand the
specific function of these hormones and to address possible
autocrine and/or paracrine effects under normal and pathological
conditions opening new perspectives in clinical settings.
Neuroimmunomodulation
occurs also at the periphery where important interactions between
immune, endocrine, and nervous products and functions appear
to be evident. Natural killer cells, gd T lymphocytes
and CD-5+
lymphocytes, are key mediators of the natural immunity. NK cytotoxicity
is regulated by cytokines and hormones such as IL-2, INFs, prolactin
and GH, while the regulation of gd T lymphocytes and CD-5+
lymphocytes is less investigated. It seems that, for example,
CD-5+
lymphocytes produce germline coded natural antibodies that are
polyspecific and able to recognize a great variety of microorganisms,
cancer cells and selfcomponents.
NIM is an important
component also in the control of the salivary secretion by nitric
oxide. In fact in many experiments, exposure to endotoxins such
as LPS leads to a co-induction of inducible nitric oxide synthase
(iNOS) and cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2) that are important in the
pathophysiology of infection. Nerve growth factor (NGF) and
neurotrophins (NTs) represent other important mediators of NIM.
In fact NGF has trophic and topic effects on nerves and direct
and indirect effects on immunocompetent cells such as for example
modulation of lymphocyte functions, activation of mast cells
and release of histamine, stimulation of hematopoietic cells
and differentiation of eosinophils and basophils/mast cells.
Moreover NGF is increased in chronic inflammatory diseases such
as rheumatoid arthritis, gastrointestinal parasitic infections,
hyperalgesia, allergic reactions and chronic rhinitis. Concerning
NTs there is evidence for mutual interactions between NTs and
cytokines. In glial cells different transcription factors such
as NF-kB, c-AMP-responsive element binding protein (CREB) and
activator protein 1 (AP-1) are involved in NT induction. An
important role of IL-6 in connection with NTs has been reported:
in fact, it seems that IL-6 with its receptor induces a specific
pattern of NTs in astrocytes in certain brain regions indicating
that the IL-6 system mediates a local supply of NTs that participates
in diverse functions of CNS such as protection of neurons from
insults, neural survival and neuroimmune response.
The bidirectional
communication between the nervous and immune system involves
also classical neurotransmitters such as catecholamines which
are produced not only by nervous cells but even by immunocompetent
cells (lymphocytes) and a down regulation between the two systems
is evident. IL-1 and IL-6, which represent two products of the
immune system, stimulate some products of the HPA axis such
as glucocorticoids which in turn may modulate the immune response
directly on inflammatory sites. On the other hand it has been
demonstrated that human lymphocytes produce itself products
of the HPA axis such as for example urocortin. Leukemia inhibitory
factor (LIF) which belongs to the neuropoietic cytokine family
also plays a central role in coordinating the neural and immune
responses to injury and inflammation of neurones. In fact, injury
of peripheral nerves induces the induction of LIF mRNA in Schwann
cells. The cytokine is necessary for the induction of many neuropeptides
in the injured neurones and LIF has chemotactic properties for
peritoneal macrophages. In CNS LIF is necessary for the normal
astrocyte, microglial and inflammatory reactions that follow
injury, while in periphery LIF negatively regulates neurogenic
inflammation and can be analgesic. Further studies deserve to
be done for example in Alzheimers disease and other CNS
pathologies.
Melatonin (N-acetyl-5-methoxytryptamine),
NIM and hematopoiesis represent one of the most investigated
fields of research. In particular in regard to melatonin, attention
has been focused on its immunoregulatory and antioxidant functions.
Melatonin has been largely investigated as an immunomodulator
and recently melatonin has been detected in mouse, rat and human
bone marrow: measure of N-acetyltransferase and hydroxymethyltransferase
activity and/or gene expression demonstrated that bone marrow
could represent an endogenous source of the indoleamine. Concerning
the melatonin regulation some data presented at ISNIM99 lead
to the hypothesis that the central nervous action of melatonin
is primarily mediated by membrane receptor, whereas direct effects
of melatonin in the periphery could mainly be mediated by RZR/ROR
nuclear receptor. Regarding melatonin function, it has been
confirmed that melatonin enhances IL-2 and IL-6 production by
human lymphocytic and monocytic cells. Concerning the localization
of melatonin receptor data seems to be controversial because
from one side melatonin seems to work on nuclear receptor (periphery)
and membrane receptor (CNS), while in some human cell lines
(Jurkat, U937) both nuclear (RZR/RORa) and membrane (Mel1a)
receptors have been detected.
Many researchers
are focusing their attention on the neuroimmunomodulation of
bone marrow and hematopoietic cells involving other molecules
than melatonin. In particular effects of preprotachynin-I peptides
(PPT-1) are expressed in bone marrow stromal cells and fragments
of PPT-1 (SP 1-4; SP 4-11) are involved in the production of
cytokines providing a fine regulation on hematopoiesis. Other
adrenergic and neuropeptides containing nerve fibers
project into the bone marrow and terminate in association with
stromal cells and within the parenchyma producing significant
stimulation or inhibition of hematopoiesis. Cannabinoids, such
as anandamide, stimulate hematopoietic cells growth through
a Cb2 receptor and in some conditions work in synergy with IL-3.
These synergy cannabinoids, C2b receptor, and IL-3 may play
a function in homing and/or migration of hematopoietic precursor
cells and could be involved in leukemogenic processes. Each
one of these phenomena can be connected and/or mediated by light
effects. In fact light can modulate the immune response via
the classical nervous pathway (eye - nucleus suprachiasmaticus
- hypothalamus pituitary and pineal gland) or directly
acting on the skin with a direct effect on circulating lymphocytes.
In the first case light inhibits melatonin, norepinephrin, acetylcholine,
stimulates cortisol, serotonin, GABA and DOPA, and alterates
vasointestinal peptide (VIP), gastrin-releasing peptide (GRP)
and neuropetide Y modulating mood and circadian rhythm which
in turn acts on the immune system. In the latter, direct effects
of circulating lymphocytes allow a release of interleukins and
growth factors which via autocrine and/or paracrine pathways
influence the immune response.
The complex network
including central nervous system, endocrine system and immune
system to be complete and dynamic involve many coping patterns
and adptation which considers physiological, emotional, cognitive,
behavioral and interpersonal/situational dimensions. Many models
have been presented and studies involving schizophrenia, depression,
prenatal influences, illness, normal and disturbed sleep in
connection with the immune system have been reported and are
in progress in many laboratories. For example, impaired activation
of the peripheral immune system in schizophrenic patients has
been described already long before the era of neuroleptic therapy.
However with new modern tools offered by immunocitochemistry
such as measure of sICAM, activating cytokines IL-1 and IL-2,
adhesion molecules LFA-1 and VLA-4, seem to be related to the
development of schizophrenic disease and possible therapeutic
applications are not far behind.
Psychological disturbance
and/or hormonal treatment with ACTH and dexamethasone in prenatal
individuals have been studied in monkeys model and it
seems that infants immune responses, i.e. lymphocyte proliferation,
cytolytic activity and cytokine release and anemia, continue
to show evidence of prenatal events. In cancer patients treated
with IL-2 and IFN-g a depression is frequent and this does not
seem to be correlated with the toxicity of the treatment nor
to be mediated by an alteration in the expression of cytokines
at the pituitary and brain levels but to other parameters. In
any case intersection between cytokines, immune system derangement
and depression is clear, but the exact nature of this intersection
is still elusive.
Sleep is involved
in the homeostatic regulation of the body and the immune system.
Sleep deprivation, an important illness which seems be accentuated
by the lifestyle of our era, is believed to adversely affect
host resistance to infectious diseases. Some studies correlate
the sleep deprivation with alteration of natural and cellular
immunity. At ISNIM-99 many reports were focused on the correlation
between EEG sleep measure and natural killer cell activity in
patients with major depression, the decline of immune functions
(NK activity, LAK cell activity, stimulation of IL-2 production)
in primary insomniac patients similar to patients affected by
major depression, the reduction of natural and cellular immunity
following a modest loss of sleep due to either late- or early
night partial sleep deprivation, the nocturnal sleep-related
increase of circulating levels of IL-6, and the decrease of
IL-6 and increase of IL-10 in alcoholic patients who show disordered
sleep and a prominent loss of slow wave sleep. All mechanisms
underlying the relationship between sleep and modulation of
the immune system remain unknown, but it seems that they could
have implications for understanding the physiological function
of sleep in the maintenance of health.
Oncology and neuroimmunomodulation
represent a highly investigated field as basic research. In
fact many scientists are studying connections between the immune,
the nervous and the immune system in relation to the development
of cancer. For example one of the major investigated fields
is related to the regulation of apoptosis cell death by Bcl-2
family, while other studies focused their attention on the role
of stress and chemotherapy in connection with the pineal gland
and melatonin. It is really a pity that at ISNIM-99 clinical
studies related to neuroimmunomodulation were poorly represented.
Paolo Lissoni, a real pioneer in this field, showed that IL-2,
IL-12, melatonin and other pineal hormones such as 5methoxytryptamine
and 5-methoxytryptophol may modulate the immune system and be
effective in the treatment of human neoplasms. But in oncology
a long-standing problem is the connection and link between mind
and body: the central question is whether psychological processes
can influence the immune system. Some immunologists argue that
there is insufficient evidence for a connection between the
nervous and the immune systems: others accept that there is
such a connection but deny that psychological processes could
be involved. The discussion about this important point should
be postponed to the next century or millennium!
Cytokines, which
represent mainly products of the immune system, are largely
investigated by neuroimmunologists in connection with the neuroendocrine
and nervous functions. Super-antigens such as Staphylococcal
Enterotoxin stimulate a strong response by the immune system
expressed as a clonal expansion and expression of IL-1b, IL-2,
TNF-a, IFN-g and IL-4. This immune response is followed by a
state of energy and the non-responsiveness induced by the superantigen
consisted of changes in concentration of the sympathetic neurotransmitter
noradrenaline and of serotonin in the spleen and thymus, a modification
in the ratio noradrenaline/adrenaline in adrenals and modification
of concentrations of catecholaminergic and serotoninenrgic metabolites
in brain tissues. Moreover, changes in concentration of noradrenaline,
adrenaline, corticosteroids and glucose are observed also in
the blood.
Systemic inflammation
induced by endotoxin or cytokines induce transient behavioral
(I), autonomic (II) and neuroendocrine responses (III). These
primary responses disappear after 1 day. It is important that
they induce a long lasting sensitization to a second encounter
up to three weeks. Non immune stressors such as novel environment,
footshock and amphetamine may act similar to long lasting sensitization
and the consequent activation of the immune system may induce
a reprogramming of the mechanisms of both the immune and stress
responses which can be within and outside of the brain. Alteration
of neuron hypothalamic Corticotropin Releasing Factor (CRH)
and changes in vasopressin in connection with the above mentioned
changing factors may be related to risk factors of depression.
In parallel with
this hypothesis that the immune activation can enhance the vulnerability
to stressors and represents a risk factor for depression, in
the case of dementia of the Alzheimer Type (DAT) changes related
to immuno-neuroendocrine organization have been also reported.
In fact in DAT patients, hormones belonging to the HPA axis,
GH, PRL and MLT are increased. Moreover also immune system parameters
such as NKCC, TNF-a are completely modified. If in normal physiological
aging immunoneuroendocrine parameters are preserved, DAT hormones
and NK disfunctions could contribute to altering neuroendocrine
functions. Finally, these alterations contribute to inducing
immunoneuroendocrine mechanism of neurodegeneration (I) and
dementia (II). Cytokines like IL-1b, LPC 18:0, catecholamines
and serotonin are able to stimulate the physiological production
of IL-6 by the anterior pituitary gland and, in vitro, by C6
glioma cells. About the mechanism it seems that IL-1b and LPC
18:0 may lead to a release of IL-6 via a kinase cascade which
includes cAMP proteinase.
Multiple mechanisms
related to different cytokines such as IL-1, IL-6 and TNF-a
affect the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal axis (HPA) and the
couple TNF / IL-1 exert the stimulatory action in different
types of cytokine/glucocorticoid target cells such as glioma,
pituitary, fibroblastic and epitheliod cells. In particular,
IL-1 and IL-6 induce hypothalamic increase of TRP and serotonin
and an increase of adrenal ACTH and corticosterone. On the other
hand TNF-a seem to be involved on hypothalamic noradrenaline
metabolism. Noradrenaline may be involved in response to IL-1
but not in the activation of IL-6 and TNF-a. However, the network
is clearly more complex: other molecules are able to stimulate
the HPA axis, i.e. adrenal cortex to release IL-6 and TNF and
the IL-mRNA cellular content. Among these molecules ACTH, angiotensin
II, endotoxin, serotonin, dopamine and adenosine are undoubtedly
the most representative.
Which could be the
possible role of IL-6 and TNF-a released by the adrenal cortex?
Some conclusions at ISNIM-99 speak in favor of a possible role
in adrenal function: dynamic cytokine effects on adrenal steroids
(I) and modulation of cytokines in chronic but not acute regulation
(II) seem to be implicated in adrenal functions.
In this dialogue
between brain and immune system, leptin has been suggested to
serve as a peripheral messenger to converge signals from the
periphery to the brain. In fact, this important molecule appears
to be involved in the homeostasis in pathophysiological events
occurring during infections. In the case of an infection the
HPA axis and cytokines can be deranged and frequently a weight
loss (I) and anorexia (II) are observed. In this case glucocorticoid,
endotoxin and cytokines stimulate leptines which in turn may
inhibit the HPA axis.
Hypothalamus represents
one of the terminals of the HPA axis and is a center for release
of pro- and hormones which act directly on the pituitary and
the latter participate in the paracrine and autocrine networks
by releasing hormones and cytokines. For example the hypothalamus
releases GHRH which stimulates the pituitary gland for GH. This
hormonal way is suppressed by paracrine and endocrine Insulin
Growth Factor-1 (IGF-1) whose pituitary receptor subserves negative
feed-back control of the GHRH-GH axis. GH and ACTH are also
induced by cytokines which compromise the gp130 signal transducing
subunit family, including IL-6 and LIF which receptors are expressed
on the pituitary cells. Hypothalamus and hypophysis, whose compartments
concern neural (catecholamines receptors) and glial (glucocorticoid
receptors) structures, release LHRH which acts on gonads via
the HPA axis. But LHRH interacts also with organs and cells
of the immune system. Gonads, via the release of estrogens modulate
the release and hormonal and immune functions of LHRH. In particular,
it appears that estrogens are important regulators of the differentiation
of certain brain nuclei (I), play a role in the maintenance
of normal brain life throughout the life (II), shape the activation
of the HPA axis upon stressful stimuli (III), are involved in
the regulation of the sex dysmorphism (IV) and finally they
increase the vulnerability of the female sex to autoimmune diseases
such as multiple sclerosis where the proportion with males is
2:1 (V).
Anterior pituitary
cells release a protein mediator with the same sequence of macrophage
inhibiting factor (MIF). MIF is present within corticotrophic
cells, macrophages and T cells which upon stress events (proinflammatory
stimulis and/or glucocorticoids) are released and act as antiiflammatory,
antiimmunosuppressive effects of steroid on macrophages and
T lymphocytes. The new protein mediator released by anterior
pituitary gland seems to be a new counter-regulator of glucocorticoids
action within the immune system.
A Neuroimmunomodulation
Congress without a symposium devoted to the neuroendocrine
control of thymus is not complete. In fact, thymus is known
to be considered by immunologists the central organ of the immune
system. However for neuroimmunologists, thymus belongs to the
complex network of brain, endocrine system and immune system.
As a pivotal organ murine and avian thymus and bursa of Fabricius
in avian are involved in modulating the complex glucocorticoid
cascade from cholesterol to the end products corticosterone
in cortisol. This is because the thymus possesses all enzymes
and cofactors required for glucocorticoid hormones but to be
functional in glucocorticoid metabolism the intact thymic architecture
and connection with other systems are necessary. It has been
also reported that thymus glucocorticoid production follows
a different pathway than the adrenal and the circadian rhythmicity.
The role played by glucocorticoid in the T cell development,
in the kinetic of a such an important development, researchers
are inquiring about gene marked precursor cells and thyming
homing of these cells. The main conclusion is the confirmation
that thymus is considered to be a very important organ at the
crossroads of neuroimmune interactions in which multiple cell
interactions can control developmental cell fate and the morphogenesis.
Moreover thymus, as a central organ of the immune system, is
potentially involved in the pathogenesis of several autoimmune
diseases through impaired regulation of thymocyte differentiation.
The neuroimmunomodulation
network is under the control of many hormones such as GH, prolactin,
vasopressin as well as cytokines and related molecules. However,
important molecules which have a behavioral connection should
be of a great importance: they are opioid and opiates. In fact
olfactory stimuli, which are considered naturalistic stressors
for mice, and some model of stress odor exposed such as keyhole
limpet hemocyanin (KLH) induce an increased immune response
with an increased production of IgM and IgG antibodies and analgesia.
A second restimulation of mice with KLH induces a stimulation
of TH2
cells which release IL-4. It is now clear that KLH modulates
the T cell response such as a decrease of T helper 1 (TH1)
and increase of T helper 2 (TH2)
and the consequent cytokine production. All these KLH effects
are blocked by naltrexone and/or naloxone which inhibits the
IL4 production, the analgesia and the modulation of TH1/TH2
cytokine production. In the latter KLH induces IL-4 production
while naltrexone block this metabolic way and induces IL-2 and
INFg. In parallel with opioid, morphine has been studied by
a periaqueductal injection in the brain gray matter where m
and not d or k ligands are effective in suppressing the immune
function. In fact, an inhibition of the natural killer activity
in spleen, an inhibition of the T cell proliferation in spleen
respectively thymus and an inhibition of the peritoneal macrophage
function have been reported upon morphine periaqueductal injection
in the brain gray matter. Other studies reported that morphine
injected in rat induces a decrease of blood lymphocytes independently
from the involvement of HPA axis, while the same morphine induces
an increase of circulating IL-6 which can be abrogated in adrenalectomized
rats. These morphine effects are mediated via activation of
opioid central receptors as demonstrated by the block induced
by naltrexone. Closely with opioids, cannabinoids shape antinociception,
hypothermia, sedation and hypotension. Cannabinoids and m opioid
receptors overlapped in the brain and both are present in the
immune system. Stimulation of such molecule receptors may result
in changes in different immune parameters which may be mediated
through distinct peripheral mechanisms.
Neuroimmunomodulation
includes also the large field of the mosaic represented by
autoimmune diseases. Many models are used by scientists,
among them models of collagen induced arthritis, adjuvant induced
arthritis, experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis and uveitis
are currently used as models for drug of abuse and because they
show abnormalities in corticosterone production. Genetic work
using genome wide QTL linkage technique allowed to definition
of different genomic loci QTL which are involved in the regulation
of severity/susceptibility to the above mentioned autoimmune
diseases. Scientists agree about the complexity of a study of
the genetic control of autoimmune disease. In fact autoimmune
diseases have to be associated also to neuropsychiatric feature,
anxiety, depressed mood, personality structure which are related
to disregulation of a stress response and the hormonal balance.
It is indeed the case of Sjögren Syndrome (SS), a common
autoimmune rheumatic disorder characterized by the above mentioned
factors and a hypoactivity of the HPA axis. Low ACTH and low
cortisol at the pituitary and andrenal level, alteration in
the thyroid function (Thyrotropin releasing hormone TRH). Also
in the inflammatory arthritis in rats, systemic lupus erythematosus
in mice and thyroiditis in chicken the HPA axis seems to be
a pivotal reference. In particular, when the axis is blunted
it appears to be a disregulated sympathoneural response, a defect
in the steroid (deficiency or relative deficiency of androgens/estrogen)
and neuropeptide releases and an abnormal production of cytokines
by the immune system (IL-1, TNF-a, IL-6). The consequence is
an increment of the autoimmune disease susceptibility, i.e.
rheumatoid arthritis. Although the relevance of stress in many
pathologies of autoimmune diseases, allergies, tumors, etc...
is widely accepted by the scientific community, the underlying
biological mechanisms of stress-related exacerbation of symptoms
related to these pathologies are not completely understood.
Among different
studies related to stress should be considered the neuroendocrine
responses and allergies in which effects of enviromental factors
favoring the allergen-specific TH2
response in allergic subjects, the olfactory Pavlovian conditioning
of allergic rhinitis, the protective effect of androstenetriol
and andostenedriol against lethal radiation. Glucocorticoids
and oxidative stress play a role also in bacterial, parasite
and non-AIDS infections. In fact glucocorticoid responses have
been found to suppress inflammatory reactions by inhibiting
the traffic of immune cells. Moreover, it was demonstrated that
restraint stress and psychosocial stress differentially affected
the pathophysiology and survival in the mouse influenza model.
On the other hand oxidative stress is implicated as a pathogenic
factor in a number of viral infections such as exacerbation
of pathogenesis of coxsackievirus B3. In the specific case the
immune function and cytokine pattern post infection were altered
by the oxidative stress. Stress and glucocorticoids abrogate
also the immunity to tuberculosis and in the mouse model glucocorticoids
can cause such a TH1
to TH2
switch. It seems that the equilibrium point of the cortisol/cortisone
shuttle in infected lungs is shifted toward cortisol while the
TH1
response is declining. Then after the shift to TH2
has taken place, the equilibrium shifts towards cortisone. Physical,
social and psychological stressors disrupt physiologic homeostasis
which results in the activation of the HPA axis and is characterized
by a rise in serum glucocorticoids which in turn reduces macrophages
and T-lymphocytes activation. Androstenediol counter-regulates
the influence of stress on antiviral immune responses via cell
recruitment to the draining lymph node, lung NK cell activity,
and CD4+
T cell activation and IFN-g production. Furthermore androstenediol
blocked the influence of glucocorticoids on inflammatory cytokine
secretion, i.e. IL-1b and TNF-a. More generally hormones such
as androstenediol may function to increase the immune responses
that are important for controlling viral infection possibly
by counter-regulating glucocorticoid function as suggested at
the transcriptional level.
Other studies on
this specific neuroimmunomodulation field have been done employing
various inhalational anesthetics, i.e. halothane and nitrous
oxide (N2O).
It has been reported that these drugs are proposed to increase
fluidity of cell membrane in the CNS. The consequence is that
this process disrupts the blood-brain-barrier and promotes the
viral neuroinvasion and increases the mortality. This practice
may put certain populations, anesthetized patients and operating
room personnel, at a greater risk during viral infections. Viral
infections have been discussed in a particular session devoted
to HIV infection. The natural history of HIV infection has been
strongly influenced by the use of combined anti-retroviral therapies.
Such therapies have been found to be effective, however, some
unexpected effects such as conditions involving fat metabolism
and disruption and immune system derangements (increase IL-12,
decrease IL-10 and TNF-a, increase CD14+/DR+) seemed to be of
great importance. On the other hand some researchers focused
their presentation on pathogenic mechanisms of HIV/gp120 in
the neuroendocrine disregulation of AIDS, on changes in Cortisol/DHEA
ratio in HIV-positive men related to immunological and metabolic/nutritional
perturbations, and cytokines immunoendocrinologic axis
- glucocorticoids in HIV infections.
The proceedings
of the IV International Congress of Neuroimmunomodulation,
i.e. ISNIM-99, will be published in the last year of the millennium
by the New York Academy of Sciences and the book will records
the presentations relating to advances in the understanding
of the neuroimmunomodulation according to modern methologies
and technologies, the science of the third millennium.
Address of the
author:
Dr. Ario Conti, Ph.D.,
Center for Experimental Pathology,
Istituto Cantonale di Patologia,
6601 Locarno 1, Switzerland
E-mail: ario@bluewin.ch
TEL: +41 91 278 8884; FAX: +41 91 796 20 43
|